← Back to the blog
From the Director18 November 2026

Milburning an eternal flame*

Thoughts on a worthy but fundamentally flawed report.

The Milburn report has finally hit the world in a blistering hurricane of press coverage and bold statements about how it will re-write the social contract for the young. Big plans, big news, big … whoop?

As I suggested when I wrote about Milburn’s near-messianic reception in skill policy circles at Labour Conference this year, it is no surprise that the final report has been treated as an Important Thing by the worthies of politics and the press. It is testament to the considerably-improved media machine around Andy Burnham that a government-commissioned report into the youth labour market has claimed a place in the headlines, and even in everyday discussion of people who generally are not all that into politics let alone the management of apprenticeship policy.

And it is to be celebrated that the British state is openly acknowledging that the relationship between it and its younger citizens is wildly out of balance. It is encouraging that the mental health problems we are seeing amongst young people are getting some play as genuine effects of growing up in the shadow of economic, environmental, and epidemiological crises rather than excuses for idleness.

There is absolutely no doubt that Milburn himself has a long-standing interest in these topics, and his work is driven by a genuine belief that the state has not lived up to its promises for young people, and that not only social mobility but social reciprocity is in the balance because of this.

But, beneath the report’s bold assertions and claimed ambition, I think there is a lack of truly transformative vision which is, sadly, made all the worse by the scale and nature of the media roll-out. The political class loves a set-piece which can be sold as a game-changer, and the Labour Party especially is prey to a nostalgia-cult so powerful that anything which looks even a bit like a “founding the NHS moment” is fondly wished for. But in asserting that THIS is IT, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity that is nation-shaping, the Milburn Report is definitely being over-sold and risks seriously under-delivering.

Its most serious shortcoming is not a surprise, and indeed was baked-in from day one: a limited, even superficial, approach to higher education. Given my life for half a decade has been in that world, of course I would say this is disappointing. But I genuinely think it is more than that: for a report claiming to refashion the social contract between 18–24 year-olds and their state, it is little short of bonkers to leave off the table serious consideration of the architecture of the sector in which the majority of those people are to be found, and which spends the majority of the money allocated to that cohort by the government. You’ll find universities in the report, it’s true, but very briefly, and accompanied by proposals (credit transfer, an expanded Level 4 and 5, and serving cold spots) which are older hat than Frank Spencer’s beret. They may be good things but the report does not find space to explain why, despite being ambitions of every government since the turn of the millennium, these things have not happened, nor why anything would be different this time.

Further education is better served, and the report makes welcome recommendations on more adequately funding a sector that is so over-looked by its parents and siblings that the directed cruelty of the Ugly Sisters to Cinderella would be a significant upgrade to the ill-considered harm so often done to the college sector by both government and HE. If we’re to end the NEET problem, there has to be some education, employment, or training for the un- and under-served youth to go into, and whilst FE can and should provide a fair chunk of that, HE will also have to do so. All the work on the future skills needs of the British economy is clear that whilst entry-level training is in too-short-supply, the real gaps in serving a more prosperous economy are at higher levels which FE colleges either do not touch at all, or do so as a part of the HE system.

In fact, I have a sneaking suspicion that some of this report, and certainly the way it is being read in parts of government and the media, is not about current NEETs at all, it is about those who are in higher education but who some policymakers and commentators would rather were not. After decades of Mickey Mouse degree discourse, lots of pointing to the number of unemployed degree-holders, and the rhetorical turn against universities by a political class almost-entirely educated in them, there is very much a sense of “get yourself a trade” about this report. That may come from a good place, and may even be a valid policy choice for many, but it is frankly wishful thinking without close attention to how HE institutions are incentivised to put bums on seats not graduates in jobs by a student loans system built on systematic, knowing obfuscation about where the money comes from.

The report’s approach to schooling is also teeth-achingly under-cooked. In the early 2000s, New Labour granted broad powers of curriculum discretion to favoured schools in part to allow them to respond to the needs of their local job markets. But this didn’t work – given both nation-states and multi-national corporations pay enormous amounts of money to specialists to predict such things, it is unlikely, perhaps even delusional, to imagine schools could do so. The report implicitly acknowledges this by giving the prediction role to strategic authorities, but its recommendations to inspect work readiness suggest schools can and should respond to changes in the working world with changes to their curriculum offer fast enough to genuinely serve such needs. But by definition, school children are, on average, not very close to entering the labour market: you can get schools to teach things of purported future economic value, like coding, but you may find some skills prove to be much less useful by the time they’re looking for jobs because of wider economic changes, like coding.

It is not that schools should not be interested in preparing their students for the wider world, including the world of work, but it is a hell of a leap to assume that school teachers should privilege this over other legitimate aims of schooling, such as providing an induction into a broad-range of disciplinary thinking – especially when that aim is only achievable in schools, whereas making young people ready to take on the responsibilities of employment rests also with family and other government agencies. Given that over the past 40 years, under every party of government, careers guidance has been built up and gutted at least four times, it feels a bit much to expect teachers to fill yet another gaping hole in state capacity simply because they are legally required to have children in front of them.

A signal mark of the lack of seriousness about enduring change in the Milburn report is its recommendations for more University Technical Colleges. UTCs, introduced by Michael Gove in David Cameron’s Coalition government**, are the sort of policy which ought to be studied by life scientists keen to understand how to reanimate the dead. The best that can be said for UTCs is that the few which have survived have found a niche in their local schooling eco-system where they do little harm and sometimes some good, but there is nothing about them to suggest they could be the wave of the future. Not least that “create separate technical schools” is a policy which has been tried in some form or other by every government for more than a century and it has never worked. There is a reason that, despite it being called the TRI-partite system, no one really bothers to study the technical colleges which were to sit alongside grammar schools and secondary-moderns. Even in a system avowedly in favour of sorting the sheep from the goats, very few people were keen to build a field for llamas – especially since most of those who did do it found that what they actually had was a more expensive way of keeping sheep and/or goats.

Ultimately, I think the real problem with this report is that it isn’t really about young people’s relationship with the state overall, it is about welfare provision for people who’ve left school with few decent options and therefore drifted into unemployment. While much of its broader focus is clearly well-meant, its dive into the economic and political choices made by the British state over the last half-century and more highlights that we have a highly flexible labour market in which it is neither easy nor especially sensible for either employers or employees to engage in the sort of long-duration training we might wish them to (which is true), and then makes no proposals about changing any fundamental part of that system. Absent a genuinely holistic consideration of the places 18–24 year-olds go in great numbers (like HE) and where they don’t (employment with good long-form training options), and why that happens, enduring change is not going to come just because The Times newsletter says it should for several days in a row.

I realise that my job now appears to be “professional kill-joy”, travelling from town-to-town to hunt down any form of optimism about the future of English HE wherever it may be found, and I really, really wanted to like the report, and I should say – despite realising as I have written this that I like it even less than I had at first thought – it is overall good that this work has been done and the policy direction it points in is worthwhile. As I say, better funding for FE = good; recognising that mental health amongst young people needs some serious attention = good; but this feels to me like, at best, half an answer, which is both too ambitious in its rhetoric and not remotely ambitious enough in its plausible implementation (especially given it arrives in the midst of a “rewiring the state” sprint that itself remains pretty ill-defined).

The Milburn report lays another foundation stone in the long march towards a genuinely holistic consideration of how young people in Britain have been done-over by their elders – on housing, job security, taxation, defence, global warming, pensions, and pretty much anything else you can name – and what we ought to be obliged to do about it, but this isn’t the game-changer young people deserve. A bigger review of the whole tertiary system and the economy it sits within still waits to be done.

* alternative titles considered for this blog: “Milburn after reading”; “A Hunk A Hunk Of Milburning Love;” and “The barge she sat in, like a burnish’d throne, / Milburn’d on the water.”

** against, it might be noted, Gove’s originally sotto voce and later firmly announced opposition, and only under significant pressure from Grand Old Man of the Tory Party, Kenneth Baker.

– Professor John Blake